The Sittaford Mystery

The Sittaford Mystery is a work of detective fiction by Agatha Christie and first published in the US by Dodd, Mead and Company in 1931 under the title of The Murder at Hazelmoor and in UK by the Collins Crime Club on 7 September of the same year under Christie's original title. It is the first Christie novel to be given a different title for the US market.

The US edition retailed at $2.00 and the UK edition at seven shillings and sixpence (7/6).

Synopsis
A group of neighbours in a remote hamlet on Dartmoor decide to hold a séance during which a spirit announces that Captain Joseph Trevelyan, living six miles away at Exhampton has just been murdered.

Plot summary
(may contain spoilers - click on expand to read) Sittaford is a tiny village on the fringe of Dartmoor. Mrs Willett and her daughter Violet are the newly installed tenants of Sittaford House, a residence owned by a Trevelyan, a retired Army captain. They invite four people to tea on Friday afternoon: Captain Trevelyan's long-standing friend, Major Burnaby, Mr Rycroft, Mr Ronnie Garfield and Mr Duke. At the suggestion of Mr Garfield, the six of them decide to play a game of table-turning. During this séance, at 5.25 pm, a spirit announces that Captain Trevelyan has just been murdered. Concerned for the Captain's safety, Major Burnaby says that he intends to walk to Exhampton, a village six miles away, to see if Captain Trevelyan is alright. After four days of snow, there is already a thick layer of snow on the ground and further heavy snowfall has been forecast for later that evening. There is no telephone in Sittaford, and it is impossible to use a car because of the snow.

Two and a half hours later, just before 8 pm, in the middle of a blizzard, Major Burnaby is trudging up the path to the front door of Hazelmoor, the house in Exhampton where Captain Trevelyan now lives. When nobody answers the door, he fetches the local police and a doctor. They enter the house through the open study window at the back, and find Captain Trevelyan's dead body on the floor. Dr Warren estimates the time of death at between 5 and 6pm. A fracture of the base of the skull is the cause of death. The weapon was a green baize tube full of sand, used as a draught excluder at the bottom of the door.

Captain Trevelyan's will states that, apart from £100 for his servant Evans, his property has to be equally divided among four people: his sister Jennifer Gardner, his nephew James Pearson, his niece Sylvia Dering and his nephew Brian Pearson. Each of these four would inherit approximately £20.000. James Pearson is arrested for murder because he was in Exhampton at the time of the murder, trying unsuccessfully to get a loan from Captain Trevelyan.

While the official investigation is led by Inspector Narracott, James Pearson's fiancee Emily Trefusis starts sleuthing herself. She's assisted by Charles Enderby, a Daily Wire journalist who, the day after the murder, presented a cheque for £5000 to Major Burnaby for winning the newspaper's football competition. Emily and Charles go to stay with Mr and Mrs Curtis in Sittaford, searching for clues. Mr Dacres, James Pearson's solicitor, reveals to Emily that things look much worse than they already imagined. James has "borrowed" money from his firm to buy shares without the knowledge of the firm.

There are several red herrings. Brian Pearson, who came under suspicion when Enderby discovered him making a late-night rendezvous with Violet Willett, is Violet's fiancé. He was not in Australia, as first thought, but in England all the time. And the Willetts' motive - up to now obscure and a cause of suspicion - for moving into the isolated Sittaford house had nothing to do with any connection with Captain Trevelyan, but was in order to live close to Dartmoor Prison. An escaped convict (though later recaptured), whose escape from Dartmoor Prison three days after the murder was engineered by Brian Pearson, is Violet's father. The plan was that, after the escape, her father and Brian would live with them in the house as manservants until the danger was past. Martin Dering created a false alibi because his wife Sylvia was watching him for divorce proceedings. Sylvia is Mr Rycroft's niece; Jennifer Gardner is Mr Garfield's godmother; and Mr Duke is an Ex-Chief-Inspector of Scotland Yard.

Emily solves the mystery in Hazelmoor after finding Captain Trevelyan's ski boots hidden in the chimney and two pairs of skis in different sizes. Major Burnaby is the killer. He cleverly and opportunistically engineered the table movements during the séance to make the spirit convey the message that Captain Trevelyan had been murdered. Instead of walking the six miles in two and a half hours after the séance, he first went to his own house which was close by, put on skis, and skied the distance in a fraction of that time. He killed Captain Trevelyan about a quarter to six. Then he cleaned his skis, and put them in the cupboard. He hid Trevelyan's ski boots in the chimney and put his own in the cupboard with the other ski gear, hoping that the second pair of skis and the fact that they wouldn't fit Trevelyan would pass unnoticed.

Mr Rycroft, who is a member of the Psychical Research Society, reassembles five of the six original participants for a second séance at Sittaford House, the absent Mr Duke being replaced by Brian Pearson. The séance has scarcely begun, when Inspector Narracott steps in, in the company of Emily and Mr Duke, and charges Major Burnaby with the murder of Captain Trevelyan. Emily explains that Burnaby had lost a lot of money by buying rotten shares and his motive for the murder was to keep the cheque for £5000. Although he had denied it to Enderby and the police, he had already received the letter notifying him of the win on the morning of the day on which he murdered Trevelyan and which was actually won by Captain Trevelyan himself. Trevelyan would often use Burnaby's name to send in competition solutions because he found Sittaford House too grand an address for such correspondence. In the final chapter Emily turns down a marriage proposal by Enderby who has fallen in love with her during the investigation, because she still loves her fiancé James despite his character faults.

Inhabitants of Sittaford

 * Sittaford House: Mrs Willett and Her daughter Violet
 * Cottage 1: Major John Edward Burnaby
 * Cottage 2: Captain Wyatt and his Indian servant Abdul
 * Cottage 3: Mr Rycroft, uncle of Mr Martin Dering
 * Cottage 4: Miss Caroline Percehouse and her nephew Ronald Garfield
 * Cottage 5: Mr Curtis and his wife Amelia
 * Cottage 6: Mr Duke
 * Elmer Pound
 * Mary Hibbert

Investigators

 * Miss Emily Trefusis: James Pearson's fiancée; amateur sleuth
 * Mr Charles Enderby: journalist from the Daily Wire; amateur sleuth
 * Inspector Narracott: investigator from Exeter
 * Superintendent Maxwell: Narracott's boss
 * Constable Graves: policeman in Exhampton
 * Sergeant Pollock: policeman in Exhampton

Exhampton

 * Captain Joseph A. Trevelyan
 * Mr Robert Henry Evans, Trevelyan's servant and his wife Rebecca
 * Mrs J. Belling - proprietor, "The Three Crowns"
 * Amy
 * Miss Larpent
 * Messrs Williamson - estate agents
 * Frederick Kirkwood - Trevelyan's solicitor
 * Dr Warren
 * Amos Parker
 * Forder
 * Tom

Others

 * Jennifer Gardner and her invalid husband Robert Gardner
 * Miss Davis - Robert Gardner's nurse
 * Beatrice - maid of the Gardners
 * James Pearson: Capt Trevelyan's nephew in London
 * Mr Dacres: James Pearson's solicitor
 * Sylvia Dering: Capt Trevelyan's niece
 * Martin Dering: Sylvia's husband
 * Brian Pearson: Capt Trevelyan's nephew in New South Wales, Australia
 * “Freemantle” Freddy - convict in Dartmoor Prison, Princetown
 * Carruthers
 * Edgar Rosenkraun
 * William Martin Dering
 * Martha Rycroft
 * George Plunket
 * Belinda Plunket

Literary significance and reception
The Sittaford Mystery was the first Christie book not to be reviewed by the Times Literary Supplement.

The New York Times Book Review's issue of 16 August 1931 posited that "Mrs. Agatha Christie's latest is up to her usual high standard and compares favourably with The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, one of the best she ever did.." They went on to comment that, "Miss Trefusis is one of the sharpest and most likeable detectives of recent moons." Finally they summarised, "An excellent book to take away for week-end reading."

In a short review of 23 October 1931, the Daily Mirror said that, "A pair of snow shoes and a prize competition offer clues to the villain, who is well concealed."

Robert Barnard: "Mayhem Parva, sharpened by Dartmoor setting and snow. Many of the usual elements are here, but also escaped convict (out of Baskervilles), séances, newspaper competitions and amateur investigator – young woman torn (as in Blue Train) between handsome weakling and hardworking, upright, born-to-success type. Highly entertaining, with adroit clueing."

Charles Osborne: "..strongly plotted, and the solution to its puzzles are not likely to be arrived at by deduction on the reader's part. It is also one of Mrs. Christie's most entertaining crime novels, and her use of the Dartmoor background is masterly."

References to other works
The Sittaford Mystery contains several references to The Hound of the Baskervilles by Arthur Conan Doyle.
 * Both stories are set in Devon and have a gothic atmosphere because of the suggestion that supernatural phenomena might be involved.
 * There's an escaped convict from Dartmoor Prison in both stories: "Freemantle" Freddy in one, Selden in the other.
 * There's a naturalist in both stories: Mr Rycroft in one, Jack Stapleton in the other.
 * In chapter eleven, Charles Enderby says: "That séance business was queer too. I'm thinking of writing that up for the paper. Get opinions from Sir Oliver Lodge and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and a few actresses and people about it." Conan Doyle was actually an enthusiastic believer in parapsychology, especially in hís later years.

Geographical references
A large number of actual locations in Devon are mentioned by name in the novel, a little more than normal, it would appear. See articles Dartmoor, Exhampton, Exeter for details.

Agatha Christie's Marple
The novel was adapted as episode 4 of series 2 of ITV's Agatha Christie's Marple television series, first aired on 30 April 2006. This version made significant changes to the plot and characters including the insertion of Miss Marple into the events.

Les Petits Meurtres d'Agatha Christie
An adaptation was made as part of Season 2 of Les Petits Meurtres. The episode, entitled Mélodie mortelle, first aired on 28 September 2018. The setting was changed from a country house on Dartmoor to a Record company in Lille in the 1950s and featured a new set of investigators, commissaire Laurence, his secretary Marlene and journalist Alice Avril.

Publication history

 * 1931, Dodd Mead and Company (New York), 1931, Hardcover, 308 pp
 * 1931, Collins Crime Club (London), 7 September 1931, Hardcover, 256 pp
 * 1948, Penguin Books, Paperback, (Penguin number 690), 255 pp
 * 1950, Dell Books (New York), Paperback, (Dell number 391 [mapback]), 224 pp
 * 1961, Fontana Books (Imprint of HarperCollins), Paperback, 190 pp
 * 1973, Ulverscroft Large-print Edition, Hardcover, 387 pp, ISBN 0-85456-203-6
 * 2010, HarperCollins; Facsimile edition, Hardcover: 256 pages, ISBN 978-0-00-735459-7

In the US the novel was serialised in Good Housekeeping magazine in six instalments from March (Volume XCII, Number 3) to August 1931 (Volume XCIII, Number 2) under the title The Murder at Hazelmoor with illustrations by W. Smithson Broadhead.

Book dedication
To M.E.M. with whom I discussed the plot of this book, to the alarm of those around us.

The subject of this dedication is Christie's second husband, Max Mallowan (1904–1978) and is one of four books dedicated to him, either singly or jointly, the others being Murder on the Orient Express (1934), Come, Tell Me How You Live (1946) and Christie's final written work, Postern of Fate (1973).

During the period that The Sittaford Mystery was written, Christie faced opposition from her family with regards to Max Mallowan's proposal of marriage and her acceptance. It is probable that this opposition is what the dedication refers to. For details see here.

Dustjacket blurb
The blurb on the inside flap of the dustjacket of the first edition (which is also repeated opposite the title page) reads:

It was a typical Dickens Christmas; deep snow everywhere, and down in the little village of Sittaford on the fringe of Dartmoor, probably deeper than anywhere. Mrs Willett, the winter tenant in Captain Trevelyan’s country house, was, with her daughter Violet, giving a party. Finally they decided to do a little table rapping and after the usual number of inconsequential messages from the ‘other side’, suddenly the table announced that Captain Trevelyan was dead. His oldest friend, Captain Burnaby, was disturbed. He quickly left the house and tramped ten miles of snowy roads to Exhampton. There was no sign of life in Trevelyan’s house. A back window was broken in and the light was burning – and there, on the floor, was the body of Trevelyan. Inspector Narracott took the case in hand, and after wandering through a maze of false clues and suspects, he ultimately discovered the murderer of Captain Trevelyan. Mrs. Christie has never formulated a more ingenious or enthralling plot and her characterisation is of the vivid type which marked The Murder of Roger Ackroyd and The Murder at the Vicarage.

International titles

 * Czech: Sittafordská záhada (The Sittaford Mystery)
 * Estonian: Waimu ennustused (Prediction of the Ghost), Sittafordi saladus (The Secret of Sittaford)
 * French: Cinq heures vingt-cing (5:25)
 * German: Das Geheimnis von Sittaford (The Mystery of Sittaford)
 * Hungarian: A sittafordi rejtély (The Mystery of Sittaford)
 * Italian: Un messaggio dagli spiriti (A Message from the Spirits)
 * Portuguese: O Mistério de Sittafors (The Mystery of Sittaford)
 * Swedish: Mördande seans (Murdering séance), Borddansmysteriet (The Table-turning Mystery)
 * Turkish: Sittaford Malikanesinin Gizemi  (The Mystery of Sittaford Manor)